What should I do with my goldfish fry?

Hi Megan, I agree with you that it seems a shame to not try to hatch them but you are very sensible in not wanting the additional pressure of more lives to look after. Letting your fish eat the eggs is exactly what I would do, I would be surprised if they don't eat all the eggs before any of them hatch. Keeping them is not going to do them any favours unless you can successfully re home them.